If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.
One Piece had a direct influence on how Masashi Kishimoto developed Naruto's villains, who took the opposite approach to Eiichiro Oda
Rather than repeat One Piece's formula of pure villains, Kishimoto had Naruto go up against more nuanced, complicated characters in the manga.
Popverse's top stories of the day
- Marvel Studios (and Tide laundry detergent) invite you to an immersive, messy Captain America: Brave New World screening
- James Mangold didn't want to be "handcuffed" by so much Lucasfilm lore, so he’s giving Star Wars his Logan treatment for Wolverine
- The Traitors tl;dr: Everything you need to know about Alan Cumming's reality hit on Peacock that makes lying, backstabbing, and betrayal fun again
It is hard to find anyone in the manga and anime industry who hasn’t been directly influenced by Eiichiro Oda’s One Piece. For over 25 years, One Piece has been showing the rest of the world how to deliver big stories and iconic villains on a weekly basis. Turns out, Naruto’s creator was paying attention and taking notes – and decided that he wanted to do the opposite of One Piece’s approach to creating villains.
With some exceptions, most One Piece villains have been classic bad guys. They do bad things because they are bad, selfish, or both. That approach works well with a protagonist like Luffy, who himself represents the concept of freedom and liberation, but it wasn’t what Mashashi Kishimoto, Naruto’s creator, wanted for his series.
“It’s true that I wanted to tell human stories,” he told an event in France last year in a quote that has been translated by Twitter/X user @HowlXThree. “From the start, I had opportunities to introduce characters as super villains. But since One Piece was already doing that, I wanted to do something different with Naruto. My villain characters also had a story.”
The comparison to One Piece is apt here, as it highlights how Kishimoto and Oda had different approaches to villains. The fact is, though, that neither is inherently wrong. Having a fleshed-out, human character who does bad things like in Naruto can highlight the darkness in all of humanity, while One Piece’s big and proud villains are perfect for the grand epic that Oda has spent more than 25 years creating.
To add a small wrinkle to this comparison – and to show that time is, in fact, a circle – Mikio Ikemoto, the former assistant to Kishimoto and current artist of the Boruto manga, responded to the same question by saying how he didn’t want to copy the approach from Naruto. “I try not to duplicate what was done in Naruto. That’s why there are more purely evil villains in Boruto. Real villains.”
"In the ninja world, those who don't follow rules are trash." as Obita Uchiha once said. And while we can't say these are rules, they are the king things you'll want to read next about Naruto:
Follow Popverse for upcoming event coverage and news
Find out how we conduct our review by reading our review policy
Let Popverse be your tour guide through the wilderness of pop culture
Sign in and let us help you find your new favorite thing.
Comments
Want to join the discussion? Please activate your account first.
Visit Reedpop ID if you need to resend the confirmation email.