If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

Marvel Studios costume designer Ryan Meinerding has "no regrets" over Captain America's MCU costume not being comic-accurate

Should Captain America’s suit be fantastical? Should it be tactical? The artist responsible for the MCU design of the character weighs in

At the top of New York Comic Con 2024's Spotlight on Ryan Meinerding panel, the moderator made sure to lay the red tape on inquiring about future Marvel projects. The moderator also kindly warned the room that Marvel might gift them the Thanos “SNAP” upon any unauthorized news from anything that the Marvel Studios’ Head of Visual Development responsible for many of the iconic MCU superhero costumes might say on stage... which is to say, no Fantastic Four: First Steps dispatches leaked out. But at the Q&A mic, old discourse bubbled up.

A fan mentioned he once asked Ryan Meinerding seven years ago – yes, really – about the MCU Captain America (Chris Evans) not bearing the stuck-out wings on his helmet, with the film opting to paint it on. Evoking the fantastical flourishes popping up on Daredevil horned cowl and Alligator Loki, the fan asked if Meinerding would go back and revise his more tactical designs as “fantastical.” Meinerding said, “I understand the question,” but has no regrets about his previously grounded, tactical designs. He felt that making Cap’s helmet grounded in reality was the right choice for the Captain America movie they made.

This wasn’t the only piece of design discourse. Meinerding also referenced an incident where the internet gave a mixed reaction to the “weld mark” on an Iron Man Mark 1 suit, which an imprisoned Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) cobbled together in the cave.

“I read [about] people just so angry about that weld line, like, ‘what have I done?’” he said. “I think from my very first engagement with making something for the MCU be put online and having people react to it, you realize it's a double edged sword, right?” Given that fans will apparently return when least anticipated – seven years later – to seek clarification for old answers, perhaps the better description would be "a double edged boomerang." 


About New York Comic Con

Welcome home, hero. This is your event where you can feel unafraid to geek out. Where you’re accepted and embraced for being yourself, regardless of your cultural background, physical ability, personal identity, or self-expression. Where you can experience the best in pop culture, be inspired, get star struck, treat yourself, and create all of those memories with the people you care about the most.

Dates

-

Location

Jacob Javits Convention Center
USA

Visit the event page
×
Caroline Cao

Caroline Cao: Caroline Cao (she/her) is an NYC-based writer and Earthling who won’t shut up about cartoons, film, tv, and musical theatre. Her film/tv/theatre writing has popped up on /Film, Polygon, JoySauce, The Amp, and more. She also engages in writing chamber opera librettos. Ramen, pasta, and fanfic writing are some of her true loves.

Comments

Want to join the discussion? Please activate your account first.
Visit Reedpop ID if you need to resend the confirmation email.

View Comments (0)

Find out how we conduct our review by reading our review policy